As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We research products independently, and commissions never change our picks.

Choosing the best shower curtain starts with fabric or clear PEVA, size and how the bottom hem is weighted. 256GSM Waffle and No Hook Set are fabric designs, and Barossa Design Liner and BigFoot Clear are clear PEVA options.

Details come from the Amazon product pages for each model, so check the manufacturer instructions for size and care before the first use.

Top 4 Picks at a Glance

Top Pick

Waffle Shower Curtain 256 GSM Heavy Duty Fabric 72″x72″ Sage Green

  • 256GSM heavyweight polyester fabric
  • Water-repellent, oil-repellent and stain-repellent
  • Weighted hem and honeycomb waffle weave

Check Price on Amazon

Runner-Up

No Hook Shower Curtain with Liner Set Hotel Waffle Curtain Black 72W x 75L

  • Hook-free design with built-in rings
  • Snap-in fabric liner is removable and replaceable
  • Mesh upper panel lets in light while keeping privacy

Check Price on Amazon

Also Great

Barossa Design Oeko-tex Certified Shower Curtain Liner Standard Size, Clear

  • Works as a stand-alone shower curtain or shower liner
  • Oeko-tex Certified PEVA
  • Waterproof and quick to dry

Check Price on Amazon

Waffle Shower Curtain 256 GSM Heavy Duty Fabric 72″x72″ Sage Green

Best OverallWaffle Shower Curtain 256 GSM Heavy Duty Fabric 72"x72" Sage Green

Pros

  • 256GSM heavyweight polyester fabric
  • Water-repellent, oil-repellent and stain-repellent
  • Weighted hem and honeycomb waffle weave
Type Shower curtain
Highlights 72W x 72H inch (183W x 183H cm), 256GSM, about 1.1 pounds heavier than normal 90GSM fabric shower curtains, 12 rust-resistant grommets, heavyweight polyester fabric with a cotton feel, honeycomb waffle weave, water-repellent, oil-repellent and stain-repellent, weighted hem

256GSM Waffle is a fabric curtain, with a honeycomb waffle weave and a cotton feel to its heavyweight polyester. The surface is water-repellent, oil-repellent and stain-repellent, and a weighted hem finishes the bottom edge.

Best for: a fabric curtain where repellent properties and a weighted hem matter.

Skip it if: you do not want a heavyweight fabric curtain.

No Hook Shower Curtain with Liner Set Hotel Waffle Curtain Black 72W x 75L

Best No Hook Set PickNo Hook Shower Curtain with Liner Set Hotel Waffle Curtain Black 72W x 75L

Pros

  • Hook-free design with built-in rings
  • Snap-in fabric liner is removable and replaceable
  • Mesh upper panel lets in light while keeping privacy
Type Shower curtain
Highlights Curtain with liner set, hook-free design with built-in rings, snap-in fabric liner, removable and replaceable, waffle weave, built-in hooks install without removing the shower rod, mesh upper panel, heavy weight fabric, 2 bottom magnets, quick to dry, curtain 72″ W x 75″ L, machine wash fabric liner 71″ W x 55″ L

No Hook Set installs with built-in rings, and its built-in hooks go on without removing the shower rod. The fabric liner snaps in and can be removed or replaced, while the mesh upper panel lets light in and keeps privacy.

Best for: a curtain and liner set where a mesh upper panel matters.

Skip it if: you want to hang a curtain on separate hooks.

Barossa Design Oeko-tex Certified Shower Curtain Liner Standard Size, Clear

Best Clear Liner PickBarossa Design Oeko-tex Certified Shower Curtain Liner Standard Size, Clear

Pros

  • Works as a stand-alone shower curtain or shower liner
  • Oeko-tex Certified PEVA
  • Waterproof and quick to dry
Cons

  • Magnets are for iron-core bathtubs
Brand Barossa Design
Type Shower curtain
Highlights PEVA, Oeko-tex Certified, 3 magnets at the bottom for iron-core bathtubs, 12 metal grommet holes, rustproof metal grommets, reinforced header, waterproof, quick to dry, light weight, easy to wipe and dry, stand-alone shower curtain or shower liner use

Barossa Design Liner is a clear PEVA panel that can be used as a stand-alone shower curtain or as a shower liner. It is waterproof and quick to dry, easy to wipe and dry, with a reinforced header and rustproof metal grommets.

Best for: a clear panel that can serve as a curtain or a liner.

Skip it if: a clear finish is not what you want.

BigFoot Clear Shower Curtain, 72×72 Odorless Plastic with Magnets, Washable

Best Anti Billow PickBigFoot Clear Shower Curtain, 72x72 Odorless Plastic with Magnets, Washable

Pros

  • 8G thick premium PEVA
  • Weighted bottom hem anchors to the tub
  • Reinforced top header and metal grommets
Brand BigFoot
Type Shower curtain
Highlights 72×72, 8G thick premium PEVA to resist rips and tears, reinforced top header, metal grommets, weighted bottom hem anchors to the tub to reduce billowing, washable

BigFoot Clear is an 8G thick premium PEVA curtain made to resist rips and tears. Its weighted bottom hem anchors to the tub to reduce billowing.

Best for: a clear 72×72 curtain where a weighted bottom hem matters.

Skip it if: 72×72 is not the size you need.

How to Choose by Material, Size and Hanging Style

Material

Compare materials by name: 256GSM Waffle is heavyweight polyester fabric, No Hook Set uses heavy weight fabric with a fabric liner, and Barossa Design Liner and BigFoot Clear are PEVA. Choose 256GSM Waffle for a fabric curtain with a cotton feel, or choose Barossa Design Liner or BigFoot Clear for a clear PEVA panel.

Size

Compare sizes by name: 256GSM Waffle measures 72W x 72H inch, and BigFoot Clear measures 72×72. No Hook Set measures 72″ W x 75″ L for the curtain and 71″ W x 55″ L for the fabric liner.

Magnets and grommets

Compare hardware by name: Barossa Design Liner has 3 magnets at the bottom and 12 metal grommet holes, BigFoot Clear has a weighted bottom hem, and No Hook Set has 2 bottom magnets. 256GSM Waffle has 12 rust-resistant grommets and a weighted hem.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best shower curtain for most shoppers?

256GSM Waffle is the best pick for most shoppers, with 256GSM heavyweight polyester fabric, a honeycomb waffle weave and water-repellent, oil-repellent and stain-repellent properties.

Which shower curtains have a weighted hem?

256GSM Waffle and BigFoot Clear have a weighted hem. 256GSM Waffle pairs its weighted hem with heavyweight polyester fabric, and BigFoot Clear uses a weighted bottom hem that anchors to the tub to reduce billowing.

Final Verdict

256GSM Waffle is the best pick for most shoppers because its heavyweight polyester fabric has a cotton feel, a honeycomb waffle weave and water-repellent, oil-repellent and stain-repellent properties. No Hook Set is the alternative for a hook-free set, with a snap-in fabric liner that is removable and replaceable and a mesh upper panel for light and privacy.

Looking for something else? Browse more bath and laundry guides in our Home Gear guides.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.