As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We research products independently, and commissions never change our picks.

The best mattress topper adds comfort to a firm or aging mattress without the cost of a new bed. Thickness, fill and cooling features determine how it feels.

We compared four mattress toppers from Amazon listings. We have not lab-tested them, so our notes follow stated materials, sizes and design.

Top 4 Best Mattress Toppers

Top Pick

BEDLORE Queen Pillow Top Mattress Topper

  • Thick, soft pillow top
  • Breathable design
  • Queen size

Check Price on Amazon

Runner-Up

Niagara Sleep Solution Queen Ultra Soft Topper

  • Rayon from bamboo cover
  • Cloud-like cushion
  • Queen size

Check Price on Amazon

Also Great

WhatsBedding King Pillow Top Mattress Topper

  • Deep pocket fitted skirt
  • Breathable top promotes airflow
  • King size

Check Price on Amazon

BEDLORE Queen Pillow Top Mattress Topper

Best Pillow Top ComfortBEDLORE Queen Pillow Top Mattress Topper

Pros

  • Thick, soft pillow top
  • Breathable design
  • Queen size
Cons

  • May shift without a deep-pocket skirt
  • Thick toppers can raise bed height
Brand BEDLORE
Type Mattress topper
Highlights Queen, pillow top, breathable

BEDLORE is a thick pillow top topper meant to add plush comfort and stay cool, a good fit for firm mattresses.

Best for: Firm mattresses that need softness.

Skip it if: You want a thin topper.

Niagara Sleep Solution Queen Ultra Soft Topper

Best Bamboo Rayon CoverNiagara Sleep Solution Queen Ultra Soft Topper

Pros

  • Rayon from bamboo cover
  • Cloud-like cushion
  • Queen size
Cons

  • Not memory foam
  • Back support claims are marketing
Brand Niagara Sleep Solution
Type Mattress topper
Highlights Queen, bamboo rayon

Niagara uses a rayon-from-bamboo cover for an ultra soft feel. The listing markets it for back comfort, though results vary by sleeper.

Best for: Sleepers who like a soft, cloud-like feel.

Skip it if: You prefer a firmer foam topper.

WhatsBedding King Pillow Top Mattress Topper

Best for King BedsWhatsBedding King Pillow Top Mattress Topper

Pros

  • Deep pocket fitted skirt
  • Breathable top promotes airflow
  • King size
Cons

  • Large and heavy
  • Fitted skirt depth must match your mattress
Brand WhatsBedding
Type Mattress topper
Highlights King, pillow top, deep pocket

WhatsBedding comes in a king size with a deep pocket skirt to hold it in place, and a breathable top aimed at cooling.

Best for: King beds that need a plush layer.

Skip it if: You have a smaller bed.

OLIXIS 3 Inch Queen Memory Foam Cooling Topper

Best Memory Foam CoolingOLIXIS 3 Inch Queen Memory Foam Cooling Topper

Pros

  • 3 inch memory foam
  • Ventilated cooling gel foam
  • Contouring comfort
Cons

  • Foam can sleep warm for some
  • Heavier to move
Brand OLIXIS
Type Mattress topper
Highlights Queen, 3 in memory foam, cooling gel

OLIXIS is a three-inch memory foam topper infused with cooling gel and ventilated to reduce heat, for contouring pressure relief.

Best for: Side sleepers and hot sleepers.

Skip it if: You dislike the sink-in feel of foam.

How to Choose a Mattress Topper

Thickness and feel

Two to three inches is a common range. Thicker toppers feel plusher but change the height of your bed.

Materials

Memory foam contours, pillow top feels fluffy, and latex is springy. Choose the feel you prefer.

Fit and cooling

Deep pocket skirts keep toppers in place. If you sleep hot, look for ventilation and cooling fabrics.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a topper fix a bad mattress?

It can improve comfort on a firm mattress, but not a sagging one.

How long does a topper last?

Roughly three to five years depending on materials and use.

Final Verdict

BEDLORE is our pillow top pick, Niagara offers a soft bamboo rayon cover, WhatsBedding suits king beds and OLIXIS is the cooling memory foam choice.

Looking for something else? Browse more bedding in our Home Gear guides.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.