As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We research products independently, and commissions never change our picks.

Choosing the best ice cube tray starts with cube count, lids and release. NFK is a 4 pack with 48 cubes and a bin, Hunjazix is a 1/2 cup silicone mold, and DclobTop and WEFTNOM are 3 packs with lids.

Details come from the Amazon product pages for each tray, so check the manufacturer instructions for use and care before the first use.

Top 4 Picks at a Glance

Top Pick

Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin, 4 Pack 48 Cubes Stackable Freezer Mold

  • 4 trays, 12 cubes per tray, 48 cubes total
  • Lid blocks freezer odors, storage bin included
  • Stackable with lid on

Check Price on Amazon

Runner-Up

1/2 Cup Ice Cube Tray for Freezer, Silicone Food Freezer Molds

  • Silicone trays also work as food storage
  • Flexible easy-release bottom, push or twist
  • BPA-free food-grade silicone

Check Price on Amazon

Also Great

Ice Cube Tray with Lid, 3 Pack Silicone Easy-Release Ice Trays for Freezer, Stackable

  • Silicone base and plastic edges, easy release
  • Lid prevents spills and keeps ice fresh
  • 3 molds per set, stackable

Check Price on Amazon

Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin, 4 Pack 48 Cubes Stackable Freezer Mold

Best OverallIce Cube Tray with Lid and Bin, 4 Pack 48 Cubes Stackable Freezer Mold

Pros

  • 4 trays, 12 cubes per tray, 48 cubes total
  • Lid blocks freezer odors, storage bin included
  • Stackable with lid on
Brand NFK
Type Ice Cube Tray
Highlights Plastic and silicone, BPA free, 4 trays, 12 cubes per tray, 48 cubes total, lid blocks freezer odors, storage bin included, side notches open the lid, press or twist release, stackable with lid on, freezer mold

NFK is a 4 pack of freezer molds with 12 cubes per tray, 48 cubes total, in plastic and silicone. The lid blocks freezer odors, a storage bin is included, and the trays are stackable with the lid on, with a press or twist release.

Best for: 48 cubes in 4 trays with a lid that blocks freezer odors and a storage bin.

Skip it if: you want 1/2 cup silicone molds for soup and broth instead of cubes with a bin.

1/2 Cup Ice Cube Tray for Freezer, Silicone Food Freezer Molds

Best 1/2 Cup Mold Pick1/2 Cup Ice Cube Tray for Freezer, Silicone Food Freezer Molds

Pros

  • Silicone trays also work as food storage
  • Flexible easy-release bottom, push or twist
  • BPA-free food-grade silicone
Brand Hunjazix
Type Ice Cube Tray
Highlights Silicone trays also work as food storage for soup, broth, sauce, purees and herbs, flexible easy-release bottom, push or twist, BPA-free food-grade silicone, 1/2 cup, for freezer, food freezer molds

Hunjazix is a 1/2 cup silicone tray for the freezer, and the trays also work as food storage for soup, broth, sauce, purees and herbs. The bottom is flexible and easy-release, by push or twist, in BPA-free food-grade silicone.

Best for: 1/2 cup molds for soup, broth, sauce, purees and herbs in food-grade silicone.

Skip it if: you want trays with lids and a storage bin instead of silicone molds.

Ice Cube Tray with Lid, 3 Pack Silicone Easy-Release Ice Trays for Freezer, Stackable

Best Easy-Release PickIce Cube Tray with Lid, 3 Pack Silicone Easy-Release Ice Trays for Freezer, Stackable

Pros

  • Silicone base and plastic edges, easy release
  • Lid prevents spills and keeps ice fresh
  • 3 molds per set, stackable
Brand WEFTNOM
Type Ice Cube Tray
Highlights Silicone base and plastic edges, easy release, lid prevents spills and keeps ice fresh, food grade silicone and PP, BPA-free, 3 molds per set, stackable, rinse or dishwasher, for freezer

WEFTNOM is a 3 pack of silicone ice trays with plastic edges and an easy release. The lid prevents spills and keeps ice fresh, the molds are stackable, and care is rinse or dishwasher.

Best for: 3 silicone molds with a lid that prevents spills, stackable in the freezer.

Skip it if: you want 48 cubes in 4 trays with a bin instead of 3 molds per set.

3 Pack Ice Cube Trays with Lid for Freezer, Flexible Silicone Bottom, Stackable, 1.2 in Cubes Color-Coded

Best Color-Coded Pick3 Pack Ice Cube Trays with Lid for Freezer, Flexible Silicone Bottom, Stackable, 1.2 in Cubes Color-Coded

Pros

  • 1.2 in cubes, color-coded 2 green 1 blue
  • Individual removable spill-resistant lids
  • Flexible food-grade silicone base
Cons

  • Lids are not airtight
Brand DclobTop
Type Ice Cube Tray
Highlights Flexible food-grade silicone base, individual removable spill-resistant lids, not airtight, color-coded 2 green 1 blue, stackable, 3 pack, 1.2 in cubes, with lid for freezer

DclobTop is a 3 pack of trays for 1.2 in cubes, color-coded with 2 green and 1 blue trays and a flexible food-grade silicone base. Each tray has an individual removable spill-resistant lid, and the lids are not airtight.

Best for: 1.2 in cubes in color-coded trays with individual removable lids and a flexible silicone base.

Skip it if: you want a storage bin included instead of color-coded trays.

How to Choose by Lids, Release and Stacking

Lids

NFK has a lid that blocks freezer odors and a storage bin. DclobTop has individual removable spill-resistant lids that are not airtight, and WEFTNOM has a lid that prevents spills.

Release

Hunjazix has a flexible easy-release bottom, by push or twist, and NFK releases by press or twist. WEFTNOM is easy release with a silicone base and plastic edges.

Stacking

NFK is stackable with the lid on. DclobTop and WEFTNOM are stackable 3 packs.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best ice cube tray for most shoppers?

NFK is the best pick for most shoppers, with 4 trays, 48 cubes total, a lid that blocks freezer odors and a storage bin included.

Which ice cube trays are stackable?

NFK, DclobTop and WEFTNOM. Each of the three lists stackable in its data.

Final Verdict

NFK is the best pick for most shoppers because its 4 trays make 48 cubes with a lid that blocks freezer odors, a storage bin and stackable storage with the lid on. Hunjazix is the alternative for food molds, with 1/2 cup silicone trays for soup, broth, sauce, purees and herbs.

Looking for something else? Browse more home gear in our Home Gear guides.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.